| Αποστολή Ερωτήσεων και Σχολίων. | Aπαντήσεις των Συγγραφέων και Συζήτηση |
|---|
Anastasios G Chistodoulou, George Kapetanos. Thomas Apostoloy, John Pournaras, and Panayotis P Symeonides
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Thessaloniki School of Medicine Thessaloniki, Greece,
Correspndence: DR. A G Christodoulou, 23 Alexandrou Svolou Str. Thessaloniki 54622, Greece. Tel +30-31-281 480. Fax 200932.
30 patients with idiopathic scoliosis were treated by posterior spinal arthrodesis using the Luque (8 patients and Hartshill (22 patients) rodding systems with subliminal segmental wiring. Patients were followed for 2 to 6 years. In most cases, postoperative correction exceeded safety correction limits (lateral bending film plus 10o) .
PATIENTS AND METHODS
Final correction was 55%, while derotation was not significant (average 30). No neurological deficit was noted. Postoperative bracing was not applied and there was I patient with broken rods (Luque trolley system with out fusion) and I patient with broken wires in 4 segments.
Allogenic blood transfusion was avoided in 19 patients by preoperative donation of amologous blood, in combination with salvage of intraoperative shed blood. We found segmental spinal wiring with either rods or rectangles to be a safe method for correction of scoliosis in experienced hands. It offered satisfactory stability and fusion rate with no need for external support.
Treatment of spinal deformities using segmental instrumentation via a posterior approach is considered to be a method of choice by many orthopaedic surgeons today. Although the Harrington system in combination with compression rods was one of the earliest forms of segmental fixation, segmental spinal instrumentation by means of sublaminar wiring and fixation of 1 or 2 rods to each level of the deformity was originally described by Luque (Luque and Cardoso 1977. Luque 1982a). Although sublaminar wiring has been found reliable and safe neuromuscular scoliosis (Sullivan and Conner 1982. Allen and Ferguson 1986), complication have been reported in terms of mechanical failure and neutologic deficit (Allen and Ferguson 1981. Wilber et al. 1984. Herndon et al. 1987).
Other techniques have been developed for posterior segmental instrumentation of the spine, such as wiring of the spinous processes (Resina and Alves 1977, Drummond et al. 1984) or the Cotrel - Dubousset 1985) system of dual tods and multiple hooks. The major advantage of these methods is the decreased risk of neurological injury, although fixation may not be as secure.
On the other hand, the advantages of segmental spinal wiring include improved correction, immediate rigid fixation with no need for postoperative immobilization and diminished risk of pseudarthrosis (Luque 1982b, Allen and Ferguson 1986, Christodoulou et al. 1987), while the disadvantages include a longer operating time, greater blood loss and a risk of neurological damage with sublaminar wires.
Segmental instrumentation using sublaminar wiring of 2 Luque rods or Hartshill rectangular rod has been used at the Orthopaedic Department of the University of Thessaloniki since 1989. The incidence of broken rod and or wires, lost correction and pseudarthrosis were acceptable for the 2-6 year follow-up, while no neurological delicit was noted. This study was undertaken to assess the rate of success and complications with this method of fixation. An improved wiring technique is proposed for securing the bone grafts on their bed.
Between 1989 and 1994, 30 patients with idiopathic scoliosis were treated at the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery. Aristotelian University of Thessaloniki. They were 21 girls and 9 boys with a mean age of 15 (11-21) years. All patients underwent posterior spinal fusion and segmental spinal instrumentation using 2 Luque 1 rods (8 patients, 1989 - 1990) or a Hartshill rectangle (22 patients, 1991 - 1994) with sublaminar wiring. Spinal deformities by the Cobb method averaged 660 (450 - 1120). There were 16 thoracic (1 double thoracic). 10 thoracolymbar and 4 double major curves (right thoracic, left lumbar).
All procedures were performed by 2 of the authors and all patients were reviewed by AGC at the latest follow-up which averaged 4 (2-6) years postoperatively 3 patients who had neuromusular spinal deformity were not included in this study.
Preoperative evaluation of all patients was standard and included a neurological examination, routine blood evaluation. AP and lateral standing radiographs, right and left maximum bending radiographs, chest radiograph, electrocardiogram amd pulmonary function tests. CT or MRI were performed when indicated. Clinical photographs were taken preoperatively and 1 year postoperatively. In 10 patients who underwent fusion with a Hartshill rectangle the rotation of the apical vertebra was evaluated pre -and postoperatively by CT (Aaro and Dahlborn 1982).
The last 19 patients followed protocol of autologous blood transfusion with blood collection starting 3 to 5 weeks preoperatively. Intraoperatively salvaged red blood cells were also used. The patient under general anesthesia and prophylactic antibiotic therapy, was placed prone on the operating table with thw hips flexed. The surgical technique consisted of a standard posterior midline approach to the spine to cover the entire deformity and extended caudally to the sacrum to the subcutaneous fat only, in order to expose the right posterior iliac for obtaining the bone graft.. After exposing all the posterior elements of the spine up to the articular processes in the thoracic region, a release of the contracted soft tissues on the concave side was performed. Additionally, all the facets of the vertebrae to be fused were excised, as well as the central portion of the ligamentum flavum.
Segmental spinal instrumentation was carried out by passing 18 gauge cold - worked 316-L stainless steel wire as 2 double loops arount the lamina of each end vertecbra and as one double loop around the other laminae of the curve. This double wire was finally cut at the end and the 2 wires were separated. 2 Luque rods or a Hartshill rectangle of 0,64 cm thickness were securely fixed by twisting the wires with a Robinson jet wire twister (Luque 1982. Dove 1987). All the rods were already contoured into the appropriate Kyphosis and/or lordosis. When the correction time exceeded 60 minutes, a wake-up test was performed.
Copious autologous grafts, obtained form the outer surface of ilium, was placed in the facelectomy areas and the decorticated costotransverse processes.
| MEASURE | MEAN | CORRECTION (RANGE) | Preoperative | 600 | (450-1120) | Lateral bending | 460 | (190-800) | Discharge | 270 | (190-480) | Final follow-up | 290 | (190-480) | Loss of correction | 20 | (20-120) | Final correction | 550 |
|---|
RESULTS
Correction by preoperative bending radiographs averaged 460 (190-800), while postoperative correction on standing radiographs averaged 270 (190-480-57% correction) Figure 1). In all cases but 1, the preoperative correction was exceeded at surgery on an average of 150 (00-290).
During the first 12 months postoperatively, loss of correction ranged from 20-120 (Figure 2). After this period, no change of the curve was noted. The final result was a curve with a range between 190 and 480 (average 290, correction 55%). These results do not include I patient with broken wires and I patient with broken rods (Table 1). CT showed an average correction of rotation of 30 (00-80).
An average of 3,9 unit/patient of intraoperatively salvaged red blood cells were collected for 19 patients for reinfusion. None og these patients required allogenic transfusion. In contrast, an average of 7,1 unit/patient was required for first II patients who did not follow the autologous transfusion program.
Rods broke in only one 11 -year- old with thoracolumbar scoliosis (T8-L3) of 700 who was treated with a double L Luque rod system without fusion. The curve was corrected to 330, but one year postoperatively a kyphosis developed above the instrumented region. A second operation was performed to extend the rods up to T2 with satisfactory correction of the kyphosis. 5 months later, the original rods broke at the T12-L1 level with substantial loss of correction (curve 600). The patient was reoperated using a Cotrel-Dubousset system and bone grafting.
Wires broke in 4 patients. In 3 patients, the wires of the neutral cephalad or caudal vertebrac broke 6, 12 and 14 months postoperatively with minimal loss of correction. In the found patient with a thoracolumbar curve of 650 which had been corrected to 190 with a Hartshill rectangle, the wires broke at 4 levels, 8 months postoperatively the patient felt a snapping pain and a 220 loss of correction was seen radiographically. The patient refused reoperation and a final correction of 450 was achieved by bracing.
Sliding between the L-rods was observed in 6 patients (Figure 3). The ends had completely disengaged in 2 patients without loss of correction, but with a difference between pre and postoperative height of 5 and 9 cm, respectively.
There were no postoperative motor or sensory deficits, and the wake-up test successful in all 30 patients.
One patient treated with 2 Luque rods, developed deep wound infection and empyema in the right pulmonary cavity. After thorough irrigation and debridement and placement of a chest drain, the infection subsided in 2 weeks. The metal work was not removed. Antibiotic therapy was given for 3 months with solid fusion and a loss of correction o 60.
DISCUSSION
The spine is a segmental structure. For maximum correction of a given deformity and maximum stabilization, the spine should be fixed at each level of the deformity. The optimum system for spinal fixation would be one which controls segmentally the entire vertebral frond, middle and back, and one which is safe and easy to use providing sufficient fixation with no need for external support and minimal incidence of complications, such as pseudarthrosis, failure of the implant and neurological deficits. Additionally the xost of the implant should be taken in account. Segmental wiring with the use of a double paravertebral bar or even better two bars welded into a rectangle, seems to fulfill many of the above criteria.
Correction of the scoliotic curve in this series was satisfactory and in most cases surpassed the "safety" limit (degrees of maximum preoperative bending correction plus 100) (Luque 1982). None of the rods or rectangles were contoured in a scoliotic shape to avoid over correction. They were placed straight and were only contoured in the appropriate kyphosis or lordosis.
The length of the operating time that correction took place by twisting gradually the wires was more than one hour. This fact in addition to the absence of any motor or sensory neurological deficit suggest that correction over the "safety" limits can be achieved. By using segmental wiring the spinal cord is not stretched as the deformity moves sideways. This is in contrast to other techniques in which distraction is applied, often leading to postoperative neurological problems (MacEwen et al. 1975. Wilber et al. 1984). Currently wa app;y as much intraoperative correction as possible and neurological deficit has been noted in 46 patients.
The Hartshill rectangle is believed to improve both stability and correction of rotation of the 2L rods system (Dove 1987). Correction of rotation was not observed in the present study, where the average correction of rotation of 30 was considered insignificant.
The complication of broken rods in the case with Luque trolleys occurred because the rods of 0.48 cm thickness were not protected by bone grafting. On the other hand, the rectangle which was 0.64 cm thick was never observed to break. It appears that the elasticity of the wires may permit some movement in the multisegmental junctions and thus, wire breakage is more common that rod breakage.
Wires that broke in this series were the cephalad and caudal ones at the level of the end vertebrae. Examination of postoperative radiographs indicated that the rectangle did not conform with the lamina and the repeated bending movement at this level lead to breakage. There are no definite guidelines on which rod size should be used, however, thicker rods which do not protrude seem to be preferable (Herndon er al. 1987). Disengagement of the ends of the L rods is undesirable and may occur either because of inadequate wiring technique or because of substatial growth. In this regard, if an increase in height is expected, L rods longer than the expected height should be chosen.
Loss of correction was minimal in the present study and occurred in the first 12 months. The incidence of broken rods and the magnitude of lost correction have been related to the absence of bone grafting (Herndon et al. 1987). Our wiring technique which combines a simple symmetric twist with a double twist over the graft and not the rod, seems to offer a satisfactory fusion, as the corticocancellous bone graft slices are well-stabilized on the decorticated costotransverse or transverse processes.
Although the need for postoperative support has been suggested by many authors (Broadstone et al. 1984. Nasca 1984, Winter 1985), our findings clearly suggest that segmental internal fixation does not require bracing, particularly not for thoracic curves (Christodoulou et al. 1987).
REFERENCES
Aaro S. Dahlborn M. The effect of Harrington instrumentation on the longitudinal axis rotation of the apical vertebra and on the spinal rib-cage deformity in idiopathic scoliosis. Studied by computed tomography. Spine 1982; 7:456-462.
Allen BL Segmental instrumentation of the spine. Indications results and complications. In: Management of Spinal deformities. (Eds. Dickson R. Bradford D) Butter-worths. Philadelphia 1984; 7:169-192.
Allen BL. Ferguson RL. Segmental instrumentation. A use-ful adjunct in the treatment of difficult spine deformities. Orthop Trans 1981. 5:191.
Allen BL., Ferguson RL. Neurological injuries with the Galveston technique of 1-rod instrumentation for scoliosis. Spine 1986; 11:14-17.
Broadstone P. Johnson JR. Holt RT. Leatherman KD. Consider postoperative immobilization of double L and SSI patients. Orthop Trans 1984; 8:171-172 (Proc. SRS).
Christodoyloy AG. Prince HG. Webb JK. Burwell GR. Adolescent idiopathic thoracic scoliosis. A prospective trial with and without bracing during postoperative care. I Bone Joint Surg: 1987; 69B: 13-16.
Cotrel Y. Duboussent J. New segmental posterior instrumentation of the spine. Orthop Trans 1985; 9: 584-585.
Crawford RJ. Sell PJ. Ali MS. Dove J Segmental spinal instrumentation. A study of the mechanical properties of materials used for sulaminar fixation. Spine 1989; 14(6): 632-635.
Dove J. Luque segmental spinal instrumentation. The use of the Hartshill rectangle Orthopaedics 1987; 10(6): 955-961.
Drummond D. Guadagni J. Keene JS. Breed A. Narechania R. Interspinous process segmental spinal instrumentation and posterior spinal fusion for idiopathic scoliosis. J Paediat Orthop 1984; 4: 405-408.
Guadagni J.R. Drummond D.S. Strength of surginal wire fixation. A laboratory study. Clin Orthop 1986; 209: 176-181.
Herndon W.A. Sullivan J.A. Yngve D.A. Gross R.H. Dreher G.. Segmental instrumentation with sublaminar wires. J. Bone Joint Surg. 1987; 69A: 851-859.
Luque ER Cardoso A. Segmental correction of scoliosis with rigid interal fixation Orthop Trans 1977; 1: 136-137.
Luque ER. The anatomic basis of and development of segmental spinal instrumentation. Spine 1982a; 7: 256-9.
Luque ER. Segmental spinal instrumentation for correction of scoliosis.Clin Orth 1982b; 163: 192-198.
Luque ER. Segmental spinal instrumentation of lumbar spine. Clin Orthop 1986; 203: 126-134.
MacEwen GD. Bunnel WP. Sriram K. Acute neurological complications in the treatment of scoliosis. A report of the Scoliosis Research Society. J Bone Joint Surg 1975; 57A: 404-408.
Nasca RJ. Early experience with segmental spinal instrumentation Ortop Trans 1984; 8: 207.
Resina J. Alves FA. A technique of correction and internal fixation for scoliosis. J Bone Joint Surg 1977; 59B: 159-177.
Sullivan JA. Conner SB. Comparison of Harrigton instrumentation and segmental spinal instrumentation in the management of neuromascular deformity. Spine 1982; 7: 299-304.
Wilber RG. Thompson GH. Shaffer JW. Brown RH. Nash CL. Postoperative neurological deficits in segmental spinal instrumentation. J Bone Joint Surg 1984; 6A: 1178-87.
Winter RB. Posterior spinal arthrodesis with instrumentation and sublaminar wiring 100 consecutive personal cases. Ortop Trans 1986; 9: 486-487.
| Αποστολή Ερωτήσεων και Σχολίων. | Aπαντήσεις των Συγγραφέων και Συζήτηση |
|---|